Table of contents

If you’ve just discovered your medical bills have landed in collections, you’re not alone. Medical debt is a significant issue in the U.S. Over 20 million adults owe more than $250 in unpaid medical bills, and the nation’s total medical debt tops $220 billion. Even with insurance, high deductibles and unexpected costs can leave you struggling to pay, and nearly one in five Americans has had a medical bill sent to collections. 

These debts can quickly damage your credit and add stress to an already tough situation. You can take steps to negotiate with debt collectors and potentially reduce what you owe. This article will show you how.

Understand Your Medical Debt

Before you contact a debt collector, get clear on what you actually owe. Start by requesting a detailed statement from both your healthcare provider and the collections agency. Check every charge for errors, billing mistakes are common and can inflate your balance. Make sure your insurance was applied correctly and that you aren’t being billed for services you didn’t receive. If you spot any discrepancies, dispute them right away. 

Also, confirm that the debt is truly yours and not outdated or already paid. Knowing exactly what you owe puts you in a stronger position to negotiate and helps you avoid paying more than necessary.

Understanding Your Financial Responsibility

To properly manage medical bills, it's important to identify which parts of the bill you're responsible for paying. Health insurance plans often have deductibles, coinsurance, and copayments that can impact how much you owe.

Deductibles are the amount you must pay out-of-pocket before your insurance starts covering the costs. After you've met your deductible, your insurance will begin covering a greater share of your medical expenses.

Coinsurance refers to the percentage of costs you must pay after meeting your deductible. For instance, if your plan includes a 20% coinsurance, you would be responsible for 20% of the bill, and your insurer would cover the remaining 80%.

Copayments are fixed amounts you pay for specific services, like doctor visits or prescriptions, and they may not count toward your deductible or coinsurance.

Make sure you know these details, as understanding your financial responsibility will help you negotiate with both your provider and debt collectors more effectively.

Verifying and Ensuring the Accuracy of Your Medical Bill

To ensure you're not overpaying or facing unwarranted charges, follow these steps to verify the accuracy of your medical bill. A careful review can help spot mistakes and clarify discrepancies. Here’s what you need to check:

  • Explanation of Benefits (EOB) vs. Itemized Bill:
    • The EOB is a summary from your insurance company that shows how much of your medical bill they’ve covered and what’s left for you to pay.
    • An itemized bill provides a detailed list of all the services and charges incurred from your healthcare provider. It's important to compare these two documents for consistency.
  • Importance of Receiving an Official Bill:

Always request an official bill from your provider instead of relying on preliminary estimates. An official bill should reflect the most accurate and up-to-date charges, including any adjustments from insurance payments or discounts.

  • Reviewing Bills Line by Line Against the EOB:
    • Go through each line of the itemized bill and compare it with the corresponding entries in your EOB.
    • Check if the services listed match what your insurance was supposed to cover and verify that your share of the costs (deductible, coinsurance, copay) is calculated correctly.
  • Common Billing Errors and Their Impact:
    • Duplicate Charges: You might be billed twice for the same service or procedure.
    • Incorrect Insurance Application: Insurance payments may not have been applied, or the wrong coverage may have been used.
    • Unbundling of Services: Sometimes, related services are billed separately rather than as a single bundled charge.
    • Wrong Codes: If the medical procedure codes are incorrect, it can lead to overcharging or denial of coverage.

By carefully verifying each element of your bill, you can avoid paying for errors and ensure that your medical debt is accurate and fair.

Exploring Financial Assistance Options

If you’re struggling with medical debt, there are several ways to seek financial support. Below are the primary methods to explore, broken down into three key areas:

Inquiry About Financial Assistance Programs from Providers

Many healthcare providers offer their own financial assistance programs, often referred to as charity care or payment assistance. These programs can help reduce your medical bills if you meet certain income and family size criteria.

  • Action Step: Contact your healthcare provider’s billing department directly to inquire about available financial assistance. Some providers might offer discounts, deferred payments, or even free care based on your financial situation.

Programs Available for Financial Support 

Several government programs are designed to assist individuals and families with healthcare costs:

  • Medicaid: A state and federally funded program that offers healthcare coverage to low-income individuals, including children, elderly adults, and people with disabilities.
  • CHIP (Children’s Health Insurance Program): Provides affordable health coverage for children in families whose income exceeds Medicaid limits but falls short of being able to afford private insurance.
  • Medicare: A federal program offering healthcare to individuals aged 65 or older, and to those under 65 with specific disabilities. Medicare can help cover hospital and medical costs.

Additionally, The Affordable Care Act (ACA) offers subsidies for insurance premiums through the Health Insurance Marketplace for those who meet specific income requirements. Some states have expanded Medicaid under the ACA, increasing eligibility for healthcare support.

Non-Profits and Foundations 

  • If you don’t qualify for provider or government programs, look to non-profits and foundations for help. Organizations like the HealthWell Foundation, PAN Foundation, and Patient Advocate Foundation offer grants or payment assistance for specific conditions or general medical debt relief.
  • Patient advocate organizations can also guide you through the application process and help negotiate your bills if you’re struggling to pay

Exploring these financial assistance options can provide crucial support, enabling you to address your medical debt without additional stress.

Negotiating with Collection Agencies

Once your medical bill has been sent to a collection agency, the next step is negotiating a manageable payment plan or settlement. Collection agencies can be intimidating, but they are often willing to work with you to resolve the debt. Here’s how you can effectively negotiate:

1. Know Your Rights

Before engaging with a collection agency, make sure you're familiar with your rights under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA). This law protects you by preventing debt collectors from using abusive or deceptive tactics. It also gives you the right to dispute the debt if you believe it is inaccurate or if you’ve already paid.

2. Review the Debt

Confirm that the debt is valid and that the amount matches what you owe. If you spot any discrepancies, bring them up with the collector. You can request a debt validation letter from the collection agency to confirm the details of the debt, including the original creditor and the amount owed.

3. Be Prepared to Negotiate

When you’re ready to negotiate, start by offering a lower payment than what is owed. Collection agencies often accept less than the full balance, especially if they know you're struggling to pay.

  • Make a lump-sum settlement: Offer a lump sum payment that is less than the full amount owed. Agencies may prefer this because they can collect the debt faster.
  • Request a payment plan: If you can’t afford a lump sum, ask for an affordable monthly payment plan. Aim for a payment you can comfortably keep up with to avoid defaulting again.

4. Ask for Written Confirmation

Any agreement made over the phone should be confirmed in writing. Ask the collection agency to provide a written settlement agreement or payment plan details before making any payments. This ensures you're protected if any issues arise later.

By being informed, prepared, and calm, you can successfully negotiate with collection agencies and reduce the financial burden of your medical debt.

Impact on Credit Scores

Medical debt sent to collections can affect your credit, but recent changes have reduced its impact. As of 2025, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) finalized a rule that removes medical bills from credit reports used by lenders, preventing debt collectors from using credit reporting to pressure payments and helping about 15 million Americans see an average credit score increase of 20 points.

Previously, only unpaid medical collections over $500 could appear on your credit report, and paid medical collections were removed entirely. There was also a 365-day grace period before medical collections appeared on your credit file, giving you time to resolve the debt.

These changes mean medical bills are less likely to hurt your credit score, but it’s still important to address them quickly and keep records of all payments and negotiations.

How Shepherd Outsourcing Collections Supports Your Debt Negotiation?

When medical bills end up in collections, Shepherd Outsourcing Collections can help ease the burden by providing personalized, stress-free solutions. Here’s how we support you:

  • Customer-Centered Approach: We focus on finding the most comfortable and convenient path for you, offering options that fit your unique needs.
  • Debt Settlement Negotiation: Shepherd negotiates with creditors to reduce the total amount owed, helping you pay less than the original balance.
  • Tailored Debt Management Plans: We create customized payment plans that work within your financial situation.
  • Legal Compliance: All negotiations follow strict legal guidelines, protecting you from unfair or aggressive collection tactics.
  • Financial Counseling: Shepherd provides guidance to help you understand your debt and make informed decisions.
  • B2B and B2C Expertise: Whether you’re a creditor or debtor, Shepherd works with both sides to facilitate fair and effective resolutions.

By partnering with Shepherd Outsourcing, you gain an experienced ally who simplifies the debt collection process and helps you regain financial control.

Conclusion

Dealing with medical bills in collections can feel overwhelming, but understanding your rights, verifying your debt, and exploring financial assistance can make a significant difference. Negotiating directly or with the help of experienced partners like Shepherd Outsourcing Collections can reduce your debt and ease financial stress. Remember, taking action early improves your chances of a favorable outcome and protects your credit. 

Ready to resolve your medical debt with confidence? Contact Shepherd Outsourcing Collections now for personalized support and effective negotiation solutions.