Shepherd Outsourcing opened its doors in 2021, and has been providing great services to the ARM industry ever since.
About
Address
©2024 by Shepherd Outsourcing.
When dealing with overdue debts, you might hear the terms "first-party" and "third-party" collections thrown around. While both are ways to recover money, some key differences exist in how they work, who’s involved, and what you can expect. Debt collection is a common experience in the U.S. financial landscape, with over 70 million adults having had their debts turned over to debt collectors. A clear picture of these differences can make it easier to navigate your options, whether you’re a debtor or a business trying to recover funds.
In this article, we’ll explore these two types of collections, dive into the details, and help you figure out which one may apply to your situation.
Let’s take a closer look at what sets them apart.
Debt collection can generally be classified into first-party and third-party collections, depending on who attempts to recover the unpaid debt. Understanding the differences between these two collection types is crucial for businesses and consumers managing outstanding debts.
First-party collections refer to the debt recovery process handled directly by the original creditor or lender. This means that the company that initially provided the credit or loan is responsible for contacting the debtor and attempting to collect the payment.
For example, the company may send reminders, emails, or phone calls to request payment if you have an overdue credit card bill. Since first-party collections involve direct communication between the creditor and the debtor, the process is typically more customer-friendly. Creditors are more likely to offer flexible repayment plans, waive late fees, or negotiate terms to maintain a good customer relationship.
However, if the debtor fails to pay within a specific timeframe—usually 90 to 180 days—the creditor may escalate the case by either hiring a third-party collection agency or selling the debt entirely.
In accounts receivable management, first-party collections are integral to maintaining a company’s financial health. The accounts receivable department or a dedicated collections team manages overdue invoices and delinquent accounts by sending reminders, negotiating payment plans, and applying late fees if necessary. Their primary goal is to recover unpaid amounts without damaging customer relationships, ensuring continued business engagement.
Third-party collections occur when an external agency, separate from the original creditor, is hired to recover the unpaid debt. In this case, the creditor either outsources the collection process to a specialized debt collection agency or sells the debt to a third-party company at a reduced price. The third-party agency then assumes the responsibility of recovering the amount owed.
3rd party debt collectors tend to be more aggressive than first-party collectors because they aim to recover as much debt as possible. They may contact debtors via phone calls, letters, and emails, and in some cases, may report unpaid debts to credit bureaus, affecting the debtor’s credit score. Additionally, third-party collectors must follow the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA), which regulates how to communicate with consumers to prevent harassment, false threats, or unethical practices.
Suppose a third-party collector cannot collect the debt. In that case, they may escalate the matter further by filing a lawsuit against the debtor or selling the debt to another collection agency.
In the accounts receivable cycle, third-party collections come into play when businesses face high delinquency rates and need external expertise to recover funds. Third-party agencies may operate in two ways:
First-party collections refer to the debt recovery efforts made directly by the original creditor or lender, such as a bank, credit card company, or service provider. These collections occur during the initial stages of delinquency and are typically handled by an in-house accounts receivable team or a dedicated collections department. Below are the key characteristics of first-party collections:
Unlike third-party collections, which involve external agencies, first-party collections are handled by the company that initially extended the credit. This means the business is responsible for contacting the debtor and attempting to recover the outstanding amount.
For example, if a customer misses a few payments on their auto loan, the bank or lending institution will personally reach out via phone, email, or mail before involving a third party.
Since the creditor wants to maintain a good relationship with the debtor, first-party collections are usually less aggressive than third-party efforts. The approach focuses on customer retention, meaning businesses are more likely to:
For instance, a hospital’s billing department may allow patients to break their medical bills into multiple installments instead of sending the account to collections.
First-party collections generally occur during the first 90 to 180 days of delinquency. If the debt remains unpaid beyond this period, the creditor may escalate the case by:
A credit card company, for example, may allow six months of internal collection efforts before deciding whether to transfer the debt to a collection agency.
In most organizations, the accounts receivable (AR) department plays a major role in first-party collections. AR specialists and collectors monitor past-due invoices, send payment reminders, and follow up with customers before the debt becomes unmanageable.
Some businesses also use automated AR software to streamline the collection process, sending alerts and reminders without human intervention.
Unlike third-party collections, first-party collection efforts do not immediately affect a debtor’s credit score. The original creditor typically waits before reporting late payments to credit bureaus, allowing debtors to settle their accounts without severe financial consequences.
However, if the account remains delinquent beyond the internal collection period, the creditor may report the missed payments, causing a drop in the debtor’s credit score.
First-party collectors are bound by company policies and industry regulations rather than federal debt collection laws like the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA), which primarily governs third-party agencies. However, they must still adhere to ethical guidelines and avoid:
While the FDCPA primarily applies to third-party collectors, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) also monitors original creditors to ensure they treat consumers fairly. This means that even if the FDCPA does not legally bind a creditor, they are still expected to follow ethical collection practices.
Third-party debt collections involve external agencies hired by creditors to recover unpaid debts after internal collection efforts fail. These agencies specialize in debt recovery and operate independently from the original creditor. Below are the key characteristics of third-party debt collections:
Unlike first-party collections, where the original creditor manages debt recovery, third-party collections involve a separate entity that takes over delinquent accounts. These agencies operate either:
For example, if a customer defaults on a credit card bill, the bank may sell the debt to a third-party agency, which will then pursue repayment.
Since third-party agencies focus solely on debt recovery, they tend to use more persistent and aggressive collection methods than first-party collectors. These may include:
While these agencies must follow legal guidelines, they are generally less concerned about maintaining customer relationships than first-party collectors.
Third-party collections usually begin after a debt has been delinquent for 90 to 180 days and the original creditor has exhausted internal efforts to collect payment.
At this stage, the creditor has either:
For instance, a telecom company may send unpaid phone bills to a collection agency after six months of non-payment.
Unlike first-party collections, third-party debt collections are usually reported to credit bureaus. Once a debt is passed to a collection agency, it can stay on the debtor's credit report for up to seven years, seriously affecting their ability to:
Because of this, many debtors prioritize settling third-party debts to avoid long-term damage to their credit.
Since third-party collectors do not own the original debt, they are heavily regulated under laws like the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) in the U.S. These laws prohibit agencies from:
Since third-party agencies operate independently, they often pursue debt settlements by offering debtors the chance to:
If debtors ignore collection efforts, agencies may escalate to legal action, such as:
Recovering debts effectively requires a balance of persistence, compliance, and a customer-focused approach. Shepherd Outsourcing provides compliant, consumer-friendly recovery solutions that prioritize efficiency and respect. As an RMAI Certified Business, we adhere to the highest industry standards, ensuring that your debt recovery processes are handled professionally and fully compliant with regulations. Partner with Shepherd Outsourcing to enhance your debt recovery efforts while maintaining the trust and confidence of your customers.
Third-party debt collection services provide businesses with an efficient and legally compliant way to recover overdue payments while minimizing financial risks. As of 2024, U.S. household debt reached nearly $17.3 trillion, indicating a significant market for debt recovery services. These agencies specialize in debt recovery, utilizing advanced tracking systems, negotiation strategies, and legal expertise to maximize collection rates.
Many agencies prefer working on a contingency basis, meaning businesses only pay if the agency successfully recovers the debt, making it a cost-effective solution. Moreover, third-party collectors make sure they follow debt collection laws, minimizing the chance of legal issues and ensuring ethical collection practices. While the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA) primarily regulates third-party collectors, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) ensures that original creditors treat consumers fairly.
This added oversight helps protect businesses from potential legal issues while maintaining a professional and respectful approach to collections. Moreover, outsourcing debt recovery helps companies preserve their brand reputation by reducing customer confrontations, preventing negative publicity, and offering structured repayment plans when necessary.
Also Read: Understanding Debt Restructuring: Process, Types & Key Benefits
When recovering unpaid debts, businesses must decide whether to handle collections in-house or outsource to a third-party agency. Both approaches have advantages and challenges, and the right choice depends on the business’s resources, goals, and customer relationships. First-party collections, managed by the original creditor, allow businesses to maintain direct control over customer interactions. This approach ensures that communication remains aligned with company values and may be beneficial for preserving long-term customer relationships.
However, first-party collections require dedicated staff, time, and expertise, which can divert resources away from core operations. Additionally, in-house teams may lack the specialized skills and legal knowledge to handle persistent non-payment cases effectively.
On the other hand, third-party debt collection agencies offer a more efficient and legally compliant way to recover debts, especially when internal efforts have been unsuccessful. Many third-party collectors operate on a contingency basis, meaning businesses only pay if debts are successfully recovered, reducing financial risk. Moreover, they ensure compliance with federal regulations like the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA). For businesses looking to streamline operations and focus on growth, outsourcing collections to a professional agency can be a strategic move.
However, choosing the right partner is essential. Businesses should prioritize agencies that use ethical practices, maintain fee transparency, and align with their customer service approach. Ultimately, while first-party and third-party collections have their place, businesses seeking efficiency, compliance, and higher recovery rates often find third-party debt collection the more effective solution.
Understanding the differences between first-party and third-party debt collections is essential for businesses aiming to recover outstanding debts efficiently. While first-party collections allow companies to maintain direct customer relationships, third-party agencies offer specialized expertise, legal compliance, and higher recovery rates. Choosing the right approach depends on factors like resources, compliance requirements, and the complexity of the debt.
If your business needs reliable support in recovering outstanding invoices, delinquent accounts, or other unpaid debts, Shepherd Outsourcing offers tailored solutions to streamline collections. With industry expertise and a compliance-first approach, they help businesses recover payments efficiently. Get in touch with Shepherd Outsourcing today!
1. What is the main difference between first-party and third-party debt collections?
A: First-party collections are handled by the original creditor, while third-party collections involve an external agency hired to recover overdue payments. Third-party collectors specialize in debt recovery and must comply with laws like the FDCPA.
2. When do businesses typically use third-party debt collection agencies?
A: Businesses usually turn to third-party agencies when internal collection efforts fail or when accounts become significantly overdue. These agencies have the expertise and legal knowledge to recover debts efficiently while ensuring compliance with debt collection regulations.
3. Are third-party debt collectors legally allowed to contact debtors?
A: Yes, third-party debt collectors can contact debtors, but they must follow strict regulations under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA). This includes restrictions on harassment, misrepresentation, and contacting debtors at inconvenient times or places.
4. Does using a third-party collection agency affect customer relationships?
A: It depends on the agency’s approach. Ethical third-party collectors use professional communication and compliance-driven strategies to recover debts while preserving customer relationships. Businesses should choose agencies that align with their values and customer service standards.
5. How can I choose the right third-party debt collection agency?
A: Look for an agency with industry experience, a strong recovery track record, and compliance with regulations like the FDCPA. Transparent fees, ethical collection practices, and a customer-centric approach are also key factors in selecting the right agency.
©2024 by Shepherd Outsourcing.